TRUE POSITIVE · EP. 02
The Monitoring Center Staffing Crisis Is a Technology Problem
Host Blake Ballard takes on one of the most uncomfortable conversations in the alarm monitoring industry: the operator staffing crisis.
Featured Guest
Blake Ballard
Host & Technical Account Manager, Actuate
Former central station operator, CSAA-certified. Blake brings first-hand experience from the alarm monitoring floor to conversations about AI, operator efficiency, and monitoring center operations.
Episode Summary
In this solo episode of True Positive, host Blake Ballard takes on one of the most uncomfortable conversations in the alarm monitoring industry: the operator staffing crisis. Rather than hide behind a guest, Blake makes his argument directly — the shortage of licensed central station operators isn’t fundamentally a hiring problem, it’s a technology problem. He opens by pointing out that the job is so invisible it doesn’t even have a clean category in the Bureau of Labor Statistics, then builds the case using data, industry commentary from The Monitoring Association CEO Whitney Doll, and his own experience sitting in an operator’s chair.
Blake walks through the true cost of the current staffing model — the licensing hurdles, the trial-by-fire training culture, and wages in the high-thirties to high-forties that still aren’t enough to retain people doing this kind of work. He then makes a deliberately narrow argument about where AI actually fits: not as a replacement for human judgment, and not as a magic solution to burnout or wages, but as a way to change what an already-stretched team spends its time on. Throughout, he transparently names his own stake — he works for Actuate, which sells AI triage software — and pushes back on the version of the pitch he refuses to make.
The episode closes with a practical Monday-morning action item and an open invitation for pushback from monitoring center leaders who disagree.
Key Insights
01
The Operator Workforce Is Statistically Invisible
Blake opens with a striking observation: in most states, there’s no clean government data on what a central station operator actually earns because the role gets folded into “security guard,” “dispatcher,” or other adjacent categories in the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This isn’t a bureaucratic footnote — it’s a symptom of how under-recognized this workforce is by everyone except the people trying to hire and retain them. When an entire job category doesn’t cleanly exist in national labor data, benchmarking wages, forecasting shortages, and building career pathways all become harder. For monitoring center executives, this means the industry can’t rely on external labor market signals the way other sectors can, which puts even more pressure on internal decisions about compensation, training, and technology.
02
Licensing Is the Hidden Tax on Every New Hire
Unlike many entry-level operations roles, alarm monitoring operators face real licensing and certification requirements — often state-specific, and often layered on top of CSAA-level training for burglar and fire alarm handling. Blake is careful not to oversimplify the requirements, but the point stands: you cannot simply put a new hire at a computer and hand them an online course. There is no universal playbook, no standardized book of “how to be a good operator.” The result is a training environment Blake describes candidly as “trial by fire,” which compounds every other pressure on the workforce — turnover, burnout, and the time-to-productivity of every new hire.
03
"Hire Your Way Out" Isn't a Working Strategy Anymore
Blake references Whitney Doll, CEO of The Monitoring Association, who called finding and retaining qualified people the number one challenge facing the industry — not one of several, the number one. Combined with security guard median wages around $38,370 and dispatcher wages near $46,860 (with 162,000 annual openings driven by attrition, not growth), the math for monitoring centers doesn’t work the way it used to. Blake is blunt: even $25/hour isn’t enough for what these operators are asked to do. The traditional lever of “add headcount” is getting more expensive and less reliable every year, which forces the conversation to shift from how many people to what those people spend their time on.
04
The Honest Case for AI — Narrower Than the Sales Pitch
This is the section where Blake deliberately slows down. As someone working for an AI triage vendor, he refuses to make the overstated claim that AI solves the staffing crisis. AI doesn’t fix burnout, doesn’t fix low wages, and doesn’t replace the judgment a trained operator brings to genuinely ambiguous calls. What it can do — and what Blake is willing to defend — is change what an existing, understaffed team spends its time on by removing alarm traffic that never needed a human look in the first place. That’s the difference between an honest technology conversation and a sales pitch, and it’s the frame monitoring center leaders should apply when evaluating any vendor.
Episode Highlights
01:29
Whitney Doll Names the Number One Challenge
“The industry has a significant gap in qualified personnel and staff turnover, and the current labor market continued to challenge the security industry.” — Whitney Doll, quoted by Blake Ballard
02:39
Trial by Fire: The Training Reality
“It’s not like when you go work fast food or Walmart, and they put you at a computer, and they say, ‘Go through this course.’ It’s so much trial by fire.” — Blake Ballard
04:21
The Wage Reality Check
“Twenty-five dollars an hour isn’t even enough, and that’s from somebody who has sat in the chair and done the job, and it’s because we ask so much of these operators.” — Blake Ballard
Top Quotes
“
In most states, there's no clean government data on what a central station operator actually earns. Not because nobody's counting, because the job just doesn't cleanly exist in the Bureau of Labor Statistics' own categories.
- Blake Ballard
“
The staffing crisis in monitoring centers isn't a hiring problem, it's a technology problem.
- Blake Ballard
“
The industry has a significant gap in qualified personnel and staff turnover, and the current labor market continued to challenge the security industry.
- Blake Ballard
SEE IT LIVE
See how Actuate cuts false alarms in your monitoring center
Bring us the three sites giving your operators the most trouble. We will run them on the cameras and the VMS you already have.
No new hardware · Onboard in minutes · BS 8418-ready